--- title: Property Development and Non-Commercial Losses description: Claiming business losses from project development requires a specific timeframe and project management --- - [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/Quantum-Business-House-152698788154774/) - [Twitter](https://twitter.com/QuantumBizHouse) - [Gplus](https://plus.google.com/+QuantumhouseAu) - [Linkedin](https://www.linkedin.com/company/quantum-business-house/) SYDNEY | MELBOURNE | BRISBANE | 1300 809 697 [![Accountants & Tax Advisers](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/QuantumHouse_October2020/images/quantum-logo-new1.png?width=560&height=472&name=quantum-logo-new1.png "Accountants & Tax Advisers")](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/) - [Home](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/) - About Us - [Who We Are](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/who-we-are/) - [Vision](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/who-we-are/vision/) - [Careers at Quantum](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/who-we-are/career-at-quantum/) - [Our Services](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/) - [Business Services & Compliances](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/business-services-business-accountants-business-services/) - [Business Setup & Closing](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/business-setup/) - [Outsourced CFO for International Companies](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/outsourced-cfo/) - [Taxation](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/taxation/) - [Assurance & Advisory](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/trust-audit-business-valuation-due-diligence/) - [Xero Accounting](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/xero-accounting/) - [R&D Tax Incentive and EMDG](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/grant-consulting/) - [International Trade & Transactions Support](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/international-trade-support/) - [Business Performance Review and Evaluation](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/business-performance-evaluation/) - [E-Commerce Automation](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/e-commerce-automation/) - [Self Managed Super Fund (SMSF)](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/self-managed-super-fund-accountant/) - [Tax Audit Guarantee Program](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/our-services/tax-audit-guarantee-program/) - [Industry](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/) - [Childcare Services](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/childcare-accountants/) - [Hospitality](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/hospitality/) - [Exporters](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/export-accounting-specialist/) - [Construction & Building](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/construction-accountants/) - [Wholesale](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/real-estate-agents/) - [Real Estate Agents](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/real-estate-agents/) - [Information Technology](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/information-technology/) - [International Traders](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/international-traders/) - [Medical Practices](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/medical-practices/) - [Legal Practices](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/industry/legal-practice/) - [Information Centre](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/) - [Business News](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/) - [Quantum Business & Tax Channel](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/quantum-business-and-tax-channel/) - [Contact Us](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/contact/) - [Client Portal](https://quantumhouse.acclipse.com/clientportal/) Search **Menu** # Property Development and Non-Commercial Losses ITAA 1997 Div 35 will apply to defer a non-commercial loss from a business activity unless: - you meet the income requirement and you pass one of the four tests - the exceptions apply, or - the Commissioner exercises his discretion. The income requirement states that an individual must defer any non-commercial losses where the other income from non-business activities exceeds $250,000. The other income also includes items such as reportable fringe benefits, reportable superannuation contributions and net investment losses. Generally, when an individual is above $250,000 in other income, the other four tests do not apply (i.e. assessable income, real property, other property, profit test). Where an individual is above $250,000, the only option available to them is ITAA 1997 s 35-55(1)(c). It states: “… for an applicant who carries on the business activity who does not satisfy (the income requirement) for the most recent income year ending before the application is made — the business activity has started to be carried on and, for the excluded years: 1. because of its nature, it has not produced, or will not produce, assessable income greater than the deductions attributable to it, and 2. there is an objective expectation, based on evidence from independent sources (where available) that, within a period that is commercially viable for the industry concerned, the activity will produce assessable income for an income year greater than the deductions attributable to it for that year.” **Property development** The term “property development” takes many forms in business. For example, individuals or partnerships may conduct and operate the business directly or via intermediaries. It is these choices which may be vital in determining whether the taxpayer can claim a deduction in property development loss years (ie the lead time). To highlight, here are two recent Private Binding Rulings: PBR 1012979759550: Taxpayer commenced business by buying a block of land, and then began operations including earthmoving and road works. The taxpayer completed all development work themselves in order to reduce overall expenditure. PBR 1051280978868: Taxpayer was in a partnership primarily concerned with property development. The business purchased a property, demolished the existing structure and was constructing a number of residential apartments. Money from a financial institution was borrowed to make this process quicker for the business. **“Hours of operations, size or scale of the activity”** The difference noted above between the taxpayer’s relevant facts and circumstances was critical for the Commissioner to exercise his discretion to allow a deduction on the loss. Operational matters such as hours worked or size and scale of operations were paramount in determining the inherent characteristics common to property development businesses. **Obtaining the Commissioner’s discretion** To obtain the Commissioner’s discretion in PBR 1051280978868, the taxpayer provided a development timeline for the project, including each of the steps involved and reasons for delay. Discretion was granted despite the taxpayer providing no evidence from independent sources surrounding the reasonableness of the delays. Also, no evidence surrounding the commercially viable period to make a profit for the industry was given. From the ruling it appears as though the Commissioner has enough information on the industry as a whole to determine whether you are operating within acceptable time frames. **Client Implications** Property developers above $250,000 in annual income should be aware that project management and development timelines are a must when commencing a property development. It will be a key factor in determining whether the Commissioner would allow a deduction for lead time losses at the top marginal tax rate. Source: CCH iKnow February 1, 2018 / by [Ben Youn](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/author/ben-youn) ##### Share this entry - Share on Facebook Share on Facebook - Share on Twitter Share on Twitter - Share on Google+ Share on Google+ - Share on Linkedin Share on Linkedin - [Share by Mail](mailto:?subject=Property%20Development%20and%20Non-Commercial%20Losses&body=https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/property-development-non-commercial-losses) Share by Mail ### RECENT ARTICLES - [![A new Property Tax coming for NSW](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/1660617614023.jpg?width=767&name=1660617614023.jpg) **A new Property Tax coming for NSW October 26, 2022**](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/a-new-property-tax-coming-for-nsw) - [![2022 -2023 Labour Federal Budget](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/2023%20Federal%20Budget.webp?width=767&name=2023%20Federal%20Budget.webp) **2022 -2023 Labour Federal Budget October 26, 2022**](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/2022-2023-labour-federal-budget) - [![Electric vehicles to be exempt from FBT](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/3000.webp?width=767&name=3000.webp) **Electric vehicles to be exempt from FBT September 16, 2022**](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/electric-vehicles-to-be-exempt-from-fbt) ### ARCHIVES - [November 2012 (18)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2012/11) - [May 2018 (8)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2018/05) - [March 2020 (8)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2020/03) - [May 2014 (3)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2014/05) - [October 2017 (3)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2017/10) - [May 2021 (3)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2021/05) - [February 2022 (3)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2022/02) - [October 2011 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2011/10) - [January 2012 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2012/01) - [April 2012 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2012/04) - [January 2013 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2013/01) - [April 2014 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2014/04) - [September 2016 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2016/09) - [January 2018 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2018/01) - [February 2018 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2018/02) - [June 2018 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2018/06) - [July 2018 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2018/07) - [September 2020 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2020/09) - [November 2020 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2020/11) - [December 2020 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2020/12) - [September 2022 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2022/09) - [October 2022 (2)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2022/10) - [March 2012 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2012/03) - [October 2012 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2012/10) - [December 2012 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2012/12) - [June 2013 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2013/06) - [April 2016 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2016/04) - [August 2016 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2016/08) - [May 2017 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2017/05) - [June 2017 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2017/06) - [September 2017 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2017/09) - [August 2018 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2018/08) - [September 2018 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2018/09) - [April 2019 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2019/04) - [January 2020 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2020/01) - [April 2020 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2020/04) - [October 2020 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2020/10) - [February 2021 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2021/02) - [August 2021 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2021/08) - [October 2021 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2021/10) - [December 2021 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2021/12) - [March 2022 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2022/03) - [June 2022 (1)](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/archive/2022/06) See all [Tax Free Lump Sum From Foreign Super Fund, Are You Sure?](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/lump-sum-not-foreign-super-fund) [Bitcoin and Tax](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/bitcoin-and-tax) ### OUR SERVICES Business Services Taxation Assurance Xero Accounting Grant Consulting ### USEFUL LINKS [ATO](https://www.ato.gov.au/) [ASIC](http://asic.gov.au/) [Business.gov.au](http://www.business.gov.au) [NSW Business](http://www.industry.nsw.gov.au/business-and-industry-in-nsw) [Business Victoria](http://www.business.vic.gov.au) [Business Queensland](https://www.business.qld.gov.au) ### INFORMATION CENTRE Articles [Taxation](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/blog-articles/taxation/) [Business News](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/blog-articles/business-news/) [Client Alert](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/clients-alert/) [Quantum News](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/business-and-tax-news/) [Quantum TV](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/business-and-tax-video/) [Seminar Silders](https://www.quantumhouse.com.au/blog-articles/seminar-slides/) ### QUANTUM HOUSE AUSTRALIA Phone : 1300 809 697 SYDNEY OFFICE Level 8, 280 Pitt St, Sydney NSW 2000 MELBOURNE OFFICE Level 24, 570 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000 © Copyright 2010 - 2026 Quantum Business House Pty Ltd "Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation" - [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/Quantum-Business-House-152698788154774/) - [Twitter](https://twitter.com/QuantumBizHouse) - [Gplus](https://plus.google.com/+QuantumhouseAu) - [Linkedin](https://www.linkedin.com/company/quantum-business-house/) [Scroll to top](https://blog.quantumhouse.com.au/information-centre/business-news/property-development-non-commercial-losses#top)